Home » Babysitters » NY » Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY Babysitters Near Me

  • Shelter Island babysitters profiles include videos, qualifications & parent reviews.
  • Browse by childcare experience, pay rate, response time, background check, and more.
  • Schedule jobs and interviews conveniently online.

Sign up now:

Available babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Eliannie

New York
$17 per hour for 1 child

"Hey there my name is Eliannie! And I'm very excited to submit my application .. I love working with kids, playing outdoors, teaching them how to discover the world & most important I LOVE READING wit..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Jacqueline

Brooklyn
$15 per hour for 1 child

"Hi! My name is Jackie and I am a 28-year-old accountant. I have babysat for 2 families in the past on a consistent basis. One family had a little girl around the age of 3 years old and the other famil..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Marian

Floral Park
$15 per hour for 1 child

"I have been an elementary school teacher for over 36 years and have worked with children ages pre-school to 12. I have both bachelor's and master's degrees in education. Additionally I have extensive ..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Krystal

Woodhaven
$15 per hour for 1 child

"My name is Krystal and I absolutely love caring for children! I was born and raised in queens new york and proud to say Im a native New yorker. Currently Im a student studying to become a nurse. I hav..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Kylah

New York
$15 per hour for 1 child

"Hi, I’m Kylah! I’m a rising senior at NYU’s Tisch School of the Arts studying Dramatic Writing (with minors in Film and Business). I have a passion for all things creative and love forming environmen..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Brittany

Huntington Station
$10 per hour for 1 child

"Hi, I'm Brittany Degel and I am a 19-year-old college student and I'm home for the summer. I am looking to babysit or be a mother's helper! I'm open to babysitting after school, for date nights or whe..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Felicia

Queens
$23 per hour for 1 child

"Hello Everyone! I am currently a Masters of Biology student at Hofstra University. I have over 6 years experience working as a babysitter in a private capacity. I have excellent references and can han..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Merlin

New York
$16 per hour for 1 child

"I am a nursing student aspiring to become an RN within then next two years . I have worked as a nursing assistant at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center for the past 2 years . I love taking care of..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Toni

Jamaica
$10 per hour for 1 child

"Hello, I'm Toni. A part time student at Farmingdale. I have been working with kids almost all of my life because I come from a huge family. I am the oldest of 5 so needless to say I have been babysitt..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Alexa

New York
$15 per hour for 1 child

"Hi! My name is Alexa and I want to thank you for your interest in my page! I'm Connecticut born and raised, turned New York City native for the past 7 years. Throughout my time here, I've helped fami..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Sign up for UrbanSitter to search Shelter Island babysitters by:

  • Background checked babysitters
  • CPR-trained babysitters
  • Spanish-speaking babysitters
  • Babysitters experienced with multiples
  • Babysitters with infant experience
  • Babysitters with a vehicle
Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

How we're different

Top picks from parents in your community

Our unique Sitter Lists show the most popular, highly-reviewed sitters as rated by parents in your school, neighborhood, church, or parents group.

Flexible plans to suit your family's needs

Become a member for peace of mind and access sitters 365 days of the year. Pay-as-you-go with an Access Pass, no subscription required.

Tried, true and trusted sitters & nannies

Rave reviews and repeat family badges set our sitters and nannies apart. Our multi-step approval process guarantees that the best, most qualified sitters are always at your fingertips.

Last minute - no problem!

Count on us for backup when you need it most: sick days, stuck working late, parent-teacher conferences. For last minute jobs, most sitters reply in 3 minutes or less.

As seen on

Discover the babysitting power of UrbanSitter. Find a babysitter. Feel great. Get going. Learn more

Looking to hire a babysitter, full-time nanny, date night babysitter, or last minute child care? Look no further than UrbanSitter, the most powerful of all babysitting websites, where you’ll find the best babysitters trusted by parents like you. Unlike traditional babysitter or nanny agencies, UrbanSitter connects you with baby sitter reviews written by parents you know and trust, and helps you book babysitters and nannies instantly on-demand.

What sets UrbanSitter apart is its amazing local network of babysitter and nanny recommendations from parents you’re connected with through school, moms and dads groups or social networks. It’s like asking every parent you know who the best babysitters are in your area, but without the legwork. Sign up for free to start your babysitter search today on the site or babysitting app. Whether you’re looking for an after-school sitter, part-time childcare, morning nanny or carpool helper, UrbanSitter has you covered.

To find babysitters in your area, start with a babysitter or nanny search by date or post a job to find available babysitters and nannies. Then, use custom filters to find a baby sitter in your neighborhood with your qualifications such as a background check, child and infant CPR certification, babysitter with car, or special needs experience. You can even save your search to be notified whenever new babysitters join and meet your requirements. If you’re looking for a last-minute backup babysitter, your best bet is to post a job for the quickest response from babysitters in your area.

Also unlike traditional babysitter agencies, you can really get to know your babysitter before making the hire. Many UrbanSitter babysitters also have education or experience with early childhood development, or have a teaching or nursing degree, which you’ll see in their detailed babysitter profiles. Babysitter profile videos, response times, number of repeat families, ratings, qualifications, and UrbanSitter reviews help you decide on the best baby sitter for your family. Why not get the whole family involved and let your kids pick their favorite babysitter based on the profile videos?

Conveniently, all babysitters in the app have an online calendar with their real time availability, so you can book a baby sitter in minutes or with a few taps from our babysitting app. You can even send a booking request to multiple babysitters, and whoever replies first will get the job while the other requests will be canceled. Hiring a babysitter for multiple dates is also quick and easy to do. Sign up for a free UrbanSitter account and hire a babysitter today!