Happy family with nanny

Find an after school nanny in Garden City, NY

After school nannies recommended by families in Garden City. Help with pickup, homework, activities, and more.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

43 experienced after school nannies in Garden City, NY

Families in Garden City use UrbanSitter to find full-time, part-time, and live-in nanny care.
Rates vary by schedule, experience, and responsibilities.

Every after school nanny is background checked annually and their profile is individually reviewed by our Trust & Safety team. Learn more.

Profile photo
Harvesta
Booked by 1 repeat family
$21 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 2 families in Garden City, NY

I am Harvesta Barthelemy, a compassionate, joyful and reliable person with Certified Nursing Assistant and Direct Support Professional background and teacher in the Sunday School Class for kids at church . I offer services as babysitter and respite care. I am experienced in kids from 3 to 14 years old. I can do cooking, laundry, light house cleaning, helping with homework, tutoring and outdoors activities. Growing up with my grandparents taught me the importance of taking care of seniors, and it reminds me of how they cared for me.

Profile photo
Shania 2 reviews
$35 per hour for 1 child

Hey, my name is Shania, and I'm from Queens, New York. I am a caring and loving individual who enjoys taking care of children. Growing up in high school, my first jobs were working in daycare and summer camps to help with the children, and I've been a private nanny for the past two years, dealing with children ages one to ten. I am a really adventurous individual who adores nature. I enjoy being a nanny because I am able to assist parents by providing a comfortable, enjoyable, imaginative, and consistent environment for their children to enjoy.

“Had Ms Shania babysit my daughter for 2 weeks and my daughter cried when she left. She's a great babysitter and is very attentive. I'd recommend her to anyone. Whenever, I come back to New York, I'll definitely have her babysit my baby girl.”

Profile photo
Denise
Booked by 1 repeat family
1 review
$20 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Garden City, NY

Hello, my name is Denise! I am 27 years old, a proud mom to a wonderful 7-year-old, and a dedicated childcare professional with a true passion for working with children. I am currently offering babysitting services and additional family support during my free time. I work full-time as a Pre-K teacher and have over four years of experience teaching toddlers. In addition, I have cared for children ranging in age from 5 months to 14 years old. My professional background has given me the skills to create a safe, nurturing, fun, and structured environment where children can learn and thrive. I earned my Associate’s Degree in Early Childhood Education from Borough of Manhattan Community College, and I will begin pursuing my Master’s Degree in May 2027 in Early Childhood Education and Special Education. I am committed to continuing my education so I can provide the best care and support possible for children and families. I am a very active, enthusiastic, and energetic person who can easily match the energy of your child while keeping them engaged in positive activities. I enjoy reading books, making arts & crafts, playing board games, practicing flashcards, and going to the park (with parent permission). I believe childcare should be both fun and enriching. I am fully vaccinated, dependable, and happy to provide references upon request. Please don’t hesitate to send me a message with any questions I would be more than happy to speak with you. Thank you for taking the time to read my introduction, and I hope to hear from you soon!

“She was wonderful, very professional and experienced with all ages. She watched my 10 month old ”

Profile photo
Lesly 2 reviews
$25 per hour for 1 child

Hello families, my name is Lesly, im 27 years old, I’m from Venezuela, living in New York. I'm an experienced childcare provider with a passion for supporting families and providing a reliable care option. I am patient, and creative, that allows me to engage with children in imaginative play and educational activities. I believe open communication is key, so I regularly update parents about their child's day via their preferred method. I'm comfortable enforcing household rules while prioritizing the parents' approach. My 2 years of experience as an aupair have equipped me to handle up to two children aged 2-14. Besides that, I’ve been babysitting toddlers, and kids since I was 16 years old. I have a college degree in modern languages and First Aid certified. I'm also bilingual in English and Spanish. I enjoy playing outdoor sports, board games, and make crafts with children, I’m also comfortable with pets. I'm excited to bring my skills and enthusiasm to your family and provide a nurturing and stimulating environment for your children.

“Lesly is a great and kind person , we worked together as au pairs for two amazing years. She’s kind and gentle with kids , she’s easy going , patient, she has a great education and she’s happy person who loves her work and life.”

Profile photo
Kashima 1 review
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Garden City, NY

I’m a certified and BLS-trained nursing student with a childcare certification and over 4 years of experience caring for children, seniors, and pets. I’ve worked with infants, toddlers, and school-aged kids handling feeding, meal prep, light cleaning, and creating fun, educational activities that promote growth and confidence. I’m patient, dependable, and calm under pressure, with a natural ability to connect and build trust. My nursing background ensures I’m attentive to safety, health, and emotional needs at all times. I’m also experienced in elder care, offering companionship, medication reminders, and mobility support. Whether it’s helping with homework, managing bedtime routines, or keeping pets happy and active, I treat every family as my own. I take pride in being reliable, professional, and caring someone you can truly depend on to keep your loved ones safe, engaged, and cared for.

“Kashima was excellent and I would definitely recommend her to any family ! ”

Live near a college or university? View after school nannies by college

Recent after school nanny activity in Garden City, NY

After school care starts with trust

Every nanny’s profile is individually reviewed by our Trust & Safety team after an annual background check. Read reviews from families in Garden City to find your fit.

Every nanny on UrbanSitter is background checked annually.

photo of quoted parent Michelle

"Johanna is AMAZING! My two boys love her - she does everything from amazing arts & crafts, to helping with homework, to getting them playing outside! She also drives them and does everything involved with after school activities: packing snacks, getting the right gear, etc."

Michelle R., mom of two

photo of quoted parent Milena

"When we hired Amani, we felt like we hit the jackpot. We were very lucky to find her on UrbanSitter at the beginning of school year. She was picking up kids from school, taking them to afternoon activities, helping them with assignments. She prepped food for them, helped organize their closets and keep their spaces neat and orderly. We would hire her again in a heartbeat."

Milena L., mom of two

photo of quoted parent Heather

"Caitlin has been such a lifesaver for our family. We hired Caitlin to help with the after school routine. The kids took to her instantly. She does it all - school pick ups, dinners, baths, lunch making, clean up, etc. She has really helped make a busy time so much easier for us."

Heather B., mom of two

Family with caregiver

Find a great fit in Garden City, NY

Create a free account to view full profiles and reviews.

Why families use UrbanSitter for after school nannies

Loved by Garden City families

Find after school nannies with reviews from families in your Garden City school, parent group, and neighborhood.

Help with school pickup and activities

Filter for nannies who can drive, then check profiles for carpool, pickup, and activity experience.

Annual background checks

Every nanny clears an annual background check and has their profile reviewed by our Trust and Safety team.

Homework help for school-age kids

Browse profiles to find nannies who can help with reading, spelling, math, projects, and daily homework.

Frequently asked questions about hiring after school nannies in Garden City

How much does an after school nanny cost in Garden City, NY?

After school nanny pay in Garden City is usually hourly and depends on the schedule, the nanny's experience, whether driving is required, and homework help. Most after school roles are part-time, in the range of 15 to 25 hours per week. See current after school nanny costs.

How do I find an after school nanny near me in Garden City?

Sign up for free, post a job with your school-year schedule and needs, then browse profiles with reviews and references from local Garden City families. Message candidates, schedule interviews, and hire when you find the right fit. Learn how UrbanSitter works.

Are after school nannies in Garden City background checked?

Yes. Every nanny in Garden City must clear an annual background check, and each profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See what's included in the background check.

Can my after school nanny drive my kids to activities in Garden City?

Yes. UrbanSitter families in Garden City can specify driving requirements when posting a job, including whether the nanny uses their own car or the family's car. Many after school nannies help with school pickup, driving to activities.

When is the best time to find an after school nanny in Garden City?

Most Garden City families start their search in late summer for an August or September start, matching the school year. Demand peaks in July and August, so families who plan ahead have the widest selection. Mid-year hiring happens too, often when schedules change or families move.

What should I look for when interviewing an after school nanny in Garden City?

Look for experience with your kids' age range, comfort with your school pickup logistics and after-school activities, references from families you trust, and a clear sense of reliability. See interview questions to ask.

Resources

Nanny Interview Questions: A Guide for Parents

Interview questions that surface experience, references, and fit.

How Much Does an After School Nanny Cost

Current rates and what factors affect the price.

As seen on