Happy family with nanny

Find an after school nanny in Muttontown, NY

After school nannies recommended by families in Muttontown. Help with pickup, homework, activities, and more.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

53 experienced after school nannies in Muttontown, NY

Families in Muttontown use UrbanSitter to find full-time, part-time, and live-in nanny care.
5 available this week | Avg weekly rate: $646.50/wk

Every after school nanny is background checked annually and their profile is individually reviewed by our Trust & Safety team. Learn more.

Profile photo
Angie $20 per hour for 1 child

I am a caring, responsible, patient, and trustworthy person who enjoys working with children. I am attentive to their safety, needs, and daily routines, and I always strive to create a warm and positive environment. I can also help with light housekeeping, organizing, meal preparation, and other household tasks. I am reliable, respectful, and hardworking.

Profile photo
Sanai
Booked by 1 repeat family
1 review
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Muttontown, NY

My name is Sanai, and I’m 20 years old. I have over five years of experience babysitting children from ages 0 to 15. I started babysitting at a young age with my family and have also helped at my church by babysitting and teaching classes. A fun fact about me is that I’m CPR certified. I enjoy engaging children in creative activities such as arts and crafts, assisting with homework, preparing meals, and organizing outdoor games. I’m available to babysit from Sunday to Friday, but on Saturdays, I attend church from morning until evening. I am dedicated to creating a safe and enjoyable environment for children.

“Sanai is very kind and timely. She is genuine and professional. I recommend 10/10. ”

Profile photo
Jamelia $20 per hour for 1 child

I am a 21-year-old Jamaican with a strong sense of responsibility, patience, and compassion. I have cared for three children between the ages of 2 to 4, providing a safe, nurturing, and attentive environment. My reliability and calm nature make me well-suited for caregiving roles.

Profile photo
Rosa $21 per hour for 1 child

Hi my name is Rosa; I have years of experience caring for my own children( who are grown adults) as well as caring for my grandchildren/family/ neighbors as well as my friends children. I am also a licensed social worker (LMSW). I have worked in foster care/ domestic violence/ crime victims and for 16 years I worked as a clinical therapist with children and adolescents;(ages 5-18) providing therapeutic services. I enjoy house work; don’t like to cook; but willing to do basic, light cooking. I love cats but unfortunately I am allergic to them. If you would like to inquire more about my experience please don’t hesitate to contact me. Thank you and I hope to hear from you soon.

Profile photo
Farhana $30 per hour for 1 child

i am new to urban sitter! Hi everybody, my name is Farhana. I have a strong background in caregiving with hands-on experience supporting kids of all ages, seniors, and even household pets, which has helped me develop the patience, empathy, and reliability families look for in a great caregiver. I’ve worked in daycares, after-school programs, and as a substitute teacher and teacher’s aide, giving me a solid understanding of child development, safety, and behavior support. My personality is warm, calm, and nurturing, and I’m skilled at creating routines, helping with homework, managing behaviors, and keeping kids engaged through fun and educational activities. I’m also comfortable assisting seniors with daily tasks and providing companionship, and I handle household responsibilities like cooking, cleaning, and organizing with ease. Altogether, my experience, strong communication, and genuine love for helping others make me a dependable and caring support for any family.

Live near a college or university? View after school nannies by college

After-school nanny with school-age kids

How much does an after school nanny cost in Muttontown, NY?

  • Average hourly rate: $25.86/hr
  • Average weekly cost (15 to 25 hrs/wk): $646.50/wk
  • Typical schedule: Monday through Friday, after school until 6 or 7 pm

As of November 2026

Recent after school nanny activity in Muttontown, NY

After school care starts with trust

Every nanny’s profile is individually reviewed by our Trust & Safety team after an annual background check. Read reviews from families in Muttontown to find your fit.

1,661 nannies background checked in Muttontown, NY

4.9 average star rating from total of 8,446 reviews in Muttontown, NY

photo of quoted parent Michelle

"Johanna is AMAZING! My two boys love her - she does everything from amazing arts & crafts, to helping with homework, to getting them playing outside! She also drives them and does everything involved with after school activities: packing snacks, getting the right gear, etc."

Michelle R., mom of two

photo of quoted parent Milena

"When we hired Amani, we felt like we hit the jackpot. We were very lucky to find her on UrbanSitter at the beginning of school year. She was picking up kids from school, taking them to afternoon activities, helping them with assignments. She prepped food for them, helped organize their closets and keep their spaces neat and orderly. We would hire her again in a heartbeat."

Milena L., mom of two

photo of quoted parent Heather

"Caitlin has been such a lifesaver for our family. We hired Caitlin to help with the after school routine. The kids took to her instantly. She does it all - school pick ups, dinners, baths, lunch making, clean up, etc. She has really helped make a busy time so much easier for us."

Heather B., mom of two

Family with caregiver

Find a great fit in Muttontown, NY

Create a free account to view full profiles and reviews.

Why families use UrbanSitter for after school nannies

Loved by Muttontown families

Find after school nannies with reviews from families in your Muttontown school, parent group, and neighborhood.

Help with school pickup and activities

Filter for nannies who can drive, then check profiles for carpool, pickup, and activity experience.

Annual background checks

Every nanny clears an annual background check and has their profile reviewed by our Trust and Safety team.

Homework help for school-age kids

Browse profiles to find nannies who can help with reading, spelling, math, projects, and daily homework.

Frequently asked questions about hiring after school nannies in Muttontown

How much does an after school nanny cost in Muttontown, NY?

As of November 2026, after school nannies in Muttontown typically cost $25.86 per hour. For a part-time schedule of 15 to 25 hours per week, that works out to about $646.50 per week. Rates vary by city, experience, driving needs, and homework help. See current after school nanny costs.

How do I find an after school nanny near me in Muttontown?

Sign up for free, post a job with your school-year schedule and needs, then browse profiles with reviews and references from local Muttontown families. Message candidates, schedule interviews, and hire when you find the right fit. Learn how UrbanSitter works.

Are after school nannies in Muttontown background checked?

Yes. Every nanny in Muttontown must clear an annual background check, and each profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See what's included in the background check.

Can my after school nanny drive my kids to activities in Muttontown?

Yes. UrbanSitter families in Muttontown can specify driving requirements when posting a job, including whether the nanny uses their own car or the family's car. Many after school nannies help with school pickup, driving to activities.

When is the best time to find an after school nanny in Muttontown?

Most Muttontown families start their search in late summer for an August or September start, matching the school year. Demand peaks in July and August, so families who plan ahead have the widest selection. Mid-year hiring happens too, often when schedules change or families move.

What should I look for when interviewing an after school nanny in Muttontown?

Look for experience with your kids' age range, comfort with your school pickup logistics and after-school activities, references from families you trust, and a clear sense of reliability. See interview questions to ask.

Resources

Nanny Interview Questions: A Guide for Parents

Interview questions that surface experience, references, and fit.

How Much Does an After School Nanny Cost

Current rates and what factors affect the price.

As seen on