"It's great, the best childcare app around."
Claudia N., babysitter, Brooklyn, NY
Find babysitting jobs in Shelter Island, NY
Shelter Island families are hiring. Browse babysitting jobs for free. Set your rate, pick your jobs, and keep 100% of your pay.
Babysitting jobs available in Shelter Island, NY
Browse jobs for free. Create a free account to view full details and apply.
Families in Shelter Island need part-time, after school, weekend, overnight, and last-minute babysitting help.
Average hourly pay in Shelter Island: $25.50/hr
Sitter needed Thursday, Nov 12, 8:30pm - 11:30pm
I’m looking for a reliable and trustworthy babysitter for my 3-year-old son for occasional date nights and evenings out. He’ll already be asleep when you arrive, so you’d mainly just need to keep an...
How much do babysitting jobs in Shelter Island, NY pay?
- Average hourly pay for 1 child: $25.50
- Average hourly pay for 2 children: $35.00
- Typical job length: 10.9 hours
- Most requested times: Evening
As of November 2026
What’s happening near you on UrbanSitter
Trust and safety for sitters
All Shelter Island families complete an authentication process before they can book. Read sitter reviews of parents, including whether sitters recommend them and why.
487 families completed authentication in Shelter Island
21 sitters reviews of Shelter Island parents
"I found a full time family to work with through UrbanSitter who I am still currently with and it's been over a year and a half now."
Arlet M., babysitter, Los Angeles, CA
"I have had really good families through the app."
Ana H., babysitter, Mercer Island, WA
Ready to find babysitting jobs in Shelter Island?
Browse Shelter Island jobs for free. Keep 100% of what you earn.
Ready to find babysitting jobs in Shelter Island?
Browse Shelter Island jobs for free. Keep 100% of what you earn.
We use email to send essential communication regarding your account.
To sign up with Facebook, we need permission to use your email address.
Sharing your friends list is optional, and allows you to meet trusted families through friends. Nothing will be shared or posted.
Why babysitters choose UrbanSitter
Work your way
Set your rates and availability. Choose the jobs you want, on your schedule.
Keep 100% of your pay
Get paid for the work you do. UrbanSitter does not take a cut from your hourly rate.
Know who you're working for
All Shelter Island families complete authentication before booking. Read sitter reviews of parents and see shared connections.
Everything in one place
Manage requests and stay organized so it's easier to keep track of what's next.
Frequently asked questions about Shelter Island babysitter-jobs
How do I find babysitting jobs in Shelter Island?
Create a free account and enter your Shelter Island location. Browse babysitting jobs for free and filter by distance, schedule, and pay to find a good fit. Get more tips in our guide to getting jobs on UrbanSitter.
How much do babysitters make in Shelter Island?
As of November 2026, the average pay in Shelter Island is $25.50/hour for 1 child. Pay varies by experience, number of kids, and responsibilities. Sitters set their own rates on UrbanSitter and keep 100% of what they earn. See average babysitting rates by city for local averages, or read how much should I charge for babysitting? for tips on setting your rate.
Are Shelter Island families vetted before they can book?
All families in Shelter Island complete an authentication process before they can book on UrbanSitter. Sitters can also read reviews of parents, including recommendations and feedback from other sitters. Learn more about trust and safety at UrbanSitter.
Can I find part-time or after school babysitting jobs in Shelter Island?
Yes. Many Shelter Island families look for part-time babysitters, including weekday after school care, weekend help, infant and toddler care, and seasonal school break coverage. Filter by day, time, and job type to find what fits your schedule.
What do I need to apply for babysitting jobs in Shelter Island?
You'll need to be at least 18 years old. To apply for jobs, you'll also need a caregiver membership, which includes a background check. For details on what's included, see UrbanSitter's caregiver approval requirements.
How much does it cost to use UrbanSitter as a Shelter Island babysitter?
It's free to create an account and search Shelter Island jobs. To apply to jobs, you'll need a caregiver membership, which includes a background check. See what's included in a caregiver membership.
Resources
How to become a babysitter: The essentials
A step-by-step guide to training, certifications, and your first job.
