Find a babysitter in Middle Island, NY

Browse background checked babysitters near you in Middle Island. Compare local reviews, rates, and experience to find the right fit.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

15 available babysitters in Middle Island, NY

Families in Middle Island use UrbanSitter for date nights, after school help, and last-minute babysitting.
32 available tonight | Avg hourly rate: $23.14/hr

All babysitters shown here are background checked every year. Learn more.

Profile photo
Jordan
Booked by 1 repeat family
2 reviews
Oakdale
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 2 families in Middle Island, NY

Hello! My name is Jordan. I have a bachelor’s degree in Early Childhood and Childhood Education with a concentration in English and a Masters degree in Literacy through Pace University! I have completed hundreds of hours student teaching as well as occasionally substituting when needed. I am originally from Long Island, New York and for the past two winters I have lived in Hawaii then Puerto Rico. I love babysitting and have been doing so since I was 12 years old for family and friends! I have experiences with a large range of ages from both babysitting and teaching. I am allergic to cats but happy to work with families with dogs. Additionally, I am open to doing some house work. I can cook, clean, and run errands.

Jordan was so great & our kids loved her. Definitely would recommend

Profile photo
Jillian
Booked by 2 repeat families
1 review
Bridgeport
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 2 families in Middle Island, NY

I’m a grandmother with over 30 years of hands-on experience caring for children of all ages. I’m patient, loving, reliable, and skilled in routines, safety, meals, and play. I’ve also supported seniors and managed household needs with care and attention.

Profile photo
Dominion 1 review
New York
$30 per hour for 1 child

Hi, I’m Dominion, and I’m a biology graduate from the college of mount Saint Vincent, NY. I used to work as a microbiologist and now preparing for my masters program. I offer reliable child care, and household services. I have a passion for babysitting and have been caring for children—from newborns to preteens, including all my little cousins during summer vacations. My experience includes school pickups, engaging activities like crafts, tutoring, and even managing dance lessons. In addition to babysitting, I could provide household support, including cleaning, and running errands. I have experience caring for my grandparents, so I'm comfortable with senior care, whether it’s preparing meals, or helping with daily tasks. My hobbies include listening to music, YouTube, shopping, working in a laboratory and reading leisurely. Looking forward to meeting you!

When my mother-in-law was unexpectedly unavailable, I reached out to Dominion and she saved the day! She arrived on time and instantly connected with my 6-month-old, which is no easy feat considering that I work from home and my daughter is super attached to me. I was instantly comforted by my daughter's smile when Dominion reached for her and by Dominion's innate ability to soothe her when she did get a bit fussy later in the day. She understood my daughter's cues, and we had a chance to laugh about them together after I had finished a few meetings. She also treated my home with great respect and showed a genuine interest in getting to know my family. I know I will continuously reach out to her when needed. Thank you, Dominion!

Profile photo
Zoe 1 review
New York
$15 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Middle Island, NY

Hi! I’m a responsible 19-year-old sitter in the Bronx with 4 years of babysitting experience. I’ve cared for children of various ages and am comfortable managing multiple kids while keeping things organized, safe, and fun. I can assist with meal prep, light household chores, and homework help — especially in ELA and Social Studies. I enjoy helping kids build confidence in reading, writing, and understanding what they’re learning. Beyond that I have plenty experience with both cats and dogs. I’m reliable, patient, and always focused on creating a positive and supportive environment for your family. Everyone needs a break sometimes and I hope to be able to provide that for you!

Zoe was a delight! She is so caring, polite, reliable, punctual and communicative while she cared for my son. My son loved her!! I Would definetely book again.

Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

Children playing together

How much does a babysitter cost in Middle Island, NY?

  • Average hourly rate for 1 child: $23.14
  • Average hourly rate for 2 children: $31.40
  • Typical job length: 1.9 hours
  • Most requested times: Afternoon

As of July 2026

Recent babysitter activity in Middle Island, NY

Trust and safety come first

Every babysitter's profile is individually reviewed by UrbanSitter's Trust & Safety team after clearing an annual background check. Rely on reviews from local families to help you find your best fit.

36 sitters background checked in Middle Island, NY

5.0 average star rating from total of 16 reviews in Middle Island, NY

photo of quoted parent Matt

"Recommendations from friends are a must when it comes to a sitter for my kids. UrbanSitter has expanded our network of babysitters, and it has given us peace of mind."

Matt K., dad of two

photo of quoted UrbanSitter parent

"UrbanSitter has supported my needs for reliable and joyful sitters. Whether it be for work, recreation or last-minute emergencies, we've made wonderful relationships with local sitters who have become a part of our family!"

Natalie O., mom of five

photo of quoted parent Laura

"UrbanSitter is my go-to for quality sitters! I can book weeks ahead of time or easily find a same-day sitter when in a bind. I even hired a part-time nanny during a daycare transition. Customer service is helpful and babysitters respond in a timely manner."

Laura F., mom of two

Sign up to find a babysitter in Middle Island

Create a free account to view full profiles and more.

How we're different

Trust and safety standards that go further

In addition to background checks, sitters are evaluated by real people to meet our gold standard for Trust & Safety.

Help when you need it, even last minute babysitters

Need a sitter today? Last-minute babysitter requests receive a response in under two minutes in most cities.

Top picks from parents in your community

See babysitters recommended by local families, including parents in your school, neighborhood, and parent groups.

Profiles that tell the full story

Compare reviews, response times, repeat families, and profile details so you can hire with confidence.

Frequently asked questions about Middle Island babysitters

How much do babysitters cost in Middle Island, NY?

As of July 2026, the average babysitting rate in Middle Island, NY is $23.14 per hour for 1 child, and $31.40 per hour for two children. Costs may vary depending on job responsibilities, children's ages, and the babysitter's experience. Try using a babysitting rates calculator as a helpful tool.

How do I find a babysitter near me?

Sign up for a free UrbanSitter account, post a job with your dates and needs, and review babysitter profiles, including distance, before choosing the right fit. Learn more about how UrbanSitter works.

Are babysitters on UrbanSitter background checked?

Yes. Every Middle Island babysitter on UrbanSitter is background checked annually, and each profile is individually reviewed by a trained specialist on our Trust & Safety team. Learn more about what's included in a background check.

What's the best way to find a last-minute babysitter in Middle Island?

Sign up for a free UrbanSitter account, then request a babysitter by posting a job with your needs. In most cities, sitters will reply within minutes, so you can review choices quickly, then book them immediately.

Can I find babysitters for after school care in Middle Island?

Yes. Families often use UrbanSitter for after school care, including pickup, homework help, tutoring, and early evening coverage. You can filter for babysitters who are willing to drive or have their own car.

Can I find babysitters for evenings, weekends, or extended hours in Middle Island?

Yes. Families in Middle Island use UrbanSitter for date nights, weekend plans, extended hours, and other scheduling needs. You can review each sitter's availability and experience to find someone who fits your hours.

Resources

The Ultimate Babysitter Guide for Parents

A step-by-step guide to hiring the right babysitter.

Tips for Finding Last-Minute Child Care

How to find a babysitter fast when plans change.

Top 20 Questions to Ask a Babysitter in an Interview

Essential questions to help you find a great fit.

As seen on