Home » Babysitters » NY » Shelter Island

Shelter Island, NY Babysitters Near Me

  • Shelter Island babysitter profiles include videos, qualifications & parent reviews.
  • Browse by childcare experience, pay rate, response time, background check, and more.
  • Schedule jobs and interviews conveniently online.

Sign up now:

5 available babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Victoria

Booked by 4 repeat families
5 reviews
New York
$15 per hour for 1 child

"I grew up on Long Island, and now I’m in Manhattan after graduating from College of the Holy Cross. I have been babysitting since I was 16. I have experience with children ranging from ages 6 months-..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

InterviewBook
Responds in 1 hour

Merrill Kaye

Booked by 35 repeat families
22 reviews
New York
$20 per hour for 1 child

"I grew up in a small town in Missouri and attended the University of Missouri-Columbia. I graduated with a degree in Theatre. I am the oldest in my family and took care of my younger brothers, as wel..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

InterviewBook
Responds in 1 hour

Karen

3 reviews
Bronx
$15 per hour for 1 child

"Hi my name is Karen and I'm from the island Jamaica and I live here for many years I grew up in a big family so having a lot of niece and nephew I was the one that watching them so it taught me a lot ..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

InterviewBook
Responds in 24 hours

Madie

Booked by 3 repeat families
2 reviews
Forest Hills
$17 per hour for 1 child

"Hi, my name is Madie. I discovered my passion of working with children at the age of 16 when I began volunteering at a childrens hospital. By 18 I was volunteering at summer camps and various child-ou..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Welselly

New York
$20 per hour for 1 child

"I'm a professional and mother building my business and looking for some additional income while my business gets off the ground. I'm great with kids and can help them with homework, and any activities..."  Sign Up to See Full Profile

Sign up for UrbanSitter to search Shelter Island babysitters by:

  • Background checked babysitters
  • CPR-trained babysitters
  • Spanish-speaking babysitters
  • Babysitters experienced with multiples
  • Babysitters with infant experience
  • Babysitters with a vehicle
Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

How we're different

Top picks from parents in your community

Our unique Sitter Lists show the most popular, highly-reviewed sitters as rated by parents in your school, neighborhood, church, or parents group.

Flexible plans to suit your family's needs

Become a member for peace of mind and access sitters 365 days of the year. Pay-as-you-go with an Access Pass, no subscription required.

Tried, true and trusted sitters & nannies

Rave reviews and repeat family badges set our sitters and nannies apart. Our multi-step approval process guarantees that the best, most qualified sitters are always at your fingertips.

Last minute - no problem!

Count on us for backup when you need it most: sick days, stuck working late, parent-teacher conferences. For last minute jobs, most sitters reply in 3 minutes or less.

As seen on