Family with caregiver

Find infant babysitters in Muttontown, NY

Meet infant babysitters Muttontown families trust, with parent reviews, background checks, and detailed profiles.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

25 experienced infant babysitters in Muttontown, NY

Families in Muttontown use UrbanSitter for date nights, newborn care, overnight babysitting, and last-minute infant sitters.
5 available today | Avg hourly rate: $25.84/hr

All babysitters shown here are background checked every year. Learn more.

Profile photo
Zaid $20 per hour for 1 child

I'm a passionate, kind, and loving person. Intro-Ambivert. I'm into soccer, video games, board games, and arts. I love cats. They're my favorite pet & I'm looking to adopt one this year, hopefully. I have nearly 2 years of soccer coaching experience as well, dealing with players between U6 - U16. Please feel free to reach out with questions, concerns, or special requests. Let's connect and discuss. :) Thank you & Take care.

Profile photo
Nicky $35 per hour for 1 child

Hello! My name is Nicky, and I am a junior in college currently available for part-time childcare. I have been babysitting for several years, primarily working with children between the ages of infant to 13. I enjoy creating a fun, safe, and engaging environment where children can learn, play, and feel comfortable. Along with childcare, I am happy to help with household responsibilities such as cooking, cleaning, laundry, and academic support. Outside of school and babysitting, I am a college student-athlete, so I love staying active and getting outside. I enjoy encouraging kids to put down the screens, get some fresh air, and have fun through outdoor activities, games, and playtime. I also have a strong passion for the arts. I enjoy theater, dance, literature, drawing, knitting, crocheting, and other creative activities. I love incorporating these interests into childcare through crafts, creative projects, reading, and imaginative play. Music is another big part of my life. I have experience with piano, percussion, guitar, and vocals, and I also offer one-on-one music lessons for children who are interested in learning an instrument or developing their vocal skills. Overall, I love working with children and creating activities that match their interests and personalities. I would be happy to help your family with childcare, homework, household tasks, creative activities, and keeping your children active and engaged!

Profile photo
Moriah
Booked by 17 repeat families
19 reviews
$26 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 26 families in Muttontown, NY

Hi! I’m Moriah, I am a first-year graduate student at New York Medical College studying Speech Pathology. I have completed one year of graduate school in Early Childhood Education with a minor in American Sign Language. I have over 6 years of experience working with children, including 4 years as a nanny and 2 years in a daycare setting with infants through Pre-K. Recently, I’ve also interned at The Fisher-Price Endowed Early Childhood Research Center in Buffalo and have cared for school-age children in before- and after-school programs. I am also partnered with SmartSitter, a childcare agency that connects families with qualified and trusted caregivers in which I provide reliable childcare services to families with children of various ages and needs. I’m dependable, nurturing, and passionate about supporting children at every stage of development, and I look forward to meeting your family! About me: I am the oldest of 2 sisters! I am a godmother to a 8 month old. I LOVE to travel, swim,read and roller skate! My favorite movie is Matilda, and my children favorite books are Wonder by R.J. Palacio and The Sour Grape by Jory John :)

“Moriah is so lovely and my kids adored her. My youngest usually cries when I leave and this time he actually waved goodbye and was so happy. She is also very proactive and had the whole kitchen cleaned up from dinner when I returned. We would definitely work with Moriah again! ”

Profile photo
Renee 1 review
$18 per hour for 1 child

Hello! My name is Renee and I am an 18 year old senior graduating 2026. I offer child care, pet care, and a bit of household services. Since as young as I can remember I have been babysitting for family members and close family friends; ranging from infants to toddlers and kids (8months - 10yo) My responsibilities include baths, entertainment, snacks, and just ensuring their well being. I worked for a summer school/camp for over 2 summers with elementary school students where I had to transport them from place to place, help with tutoring and work, and making sure they had a fun time up at site or at the school facilities. For household services I am able to run errands and do some cleaning. I have a love for pets as I have a cat myself and am comfortable with pet sitting friendly animals!! With that being said, I may not have a lot to show on my profile but I can assure you I take my jobs seriously and ensure safety. I’m always available to answer questions as well just reach out.

“Renee is a very hard working girl that does what she can to her best abilities, very much on her own pace and time. She's very good at crafts for entertainment that keeps people busy at times. She was really into baking as a kid and is trying to get into cooking as of recently. She is almost always available after school hours (2:30) or when no events are happening as she is a senior in high school. She has been babysitting for relatives/family since a younger age up until highschool. She babysat all 3 of her nephews/niece since they were babies. She loves taking care of kids and being around them. For 2 summers she worked at a summer camp as a counselor for elementary school kids and is planning on going back this summer as well. On top of that she recently adopted a cat who has been attached to her since we took her home and takes care of sher like her own child. Renee is very good with pets as long as they are docile and friendly. Though she doesn't have a car, transportation would be the main topic but given the time she always tries to be timely and prepared with her jobs.”

Profile photo
Danielle
Booked by 1 repeat family
1 review
$22 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Muttontown, NY

Hi! I’m a dedicated childcare provider who just moved back to New York after spending the last four years teaching early learners (ages 3–6) in Krakow, Poland. I absolutely love working with kids and bring a lot of patience, creativity, and calm energy to my time with them. I’m also currently earning my master’s in education through the University of Glasgow. My goal is to create a fun, safe, and cozy environment where your child feels happy and supported. I’m always happy to help however I can — can’t wait to meet your family!

“*updating as of 1/13/26: we have continued to use Danielle regularly since we first met her and are BEYOND delighted to have found her. She is amazing with our son, he is SO excited to see her, and she's super reliable - you would be lucky to have Danielle watch your children! :) They go to the park, she prepares his meals, and I really appreciate that she plays with him / is on "his level" the entire time - they have a blast and he is genuinely excited for his "friend" to come over and play. 10/10 recommend! I am delighted to recommend Danielle as a reliable, responsible, warm and dedicated caregiver! I connected with Danielle through Urban Sitter and she was super responsive / warm / organized in our initial correspondence - I then spoke with a mom in Poland who Danielle had worked for in the past who spent 30 minutes on the phone with me and could not recommend Danielle highly enough (she had cared for 3 of her sons) - we met Danielle in person last Friday and spent a few hours watching our 1.5 year old and he had the BEST time. Danielle was super calm, loving, play-oriented and very responsive to all of our directions / instructions. She took him out for a walk, prepared his dinner, and gave him lots of attention / love / play - he was in GREAT spirits when we came home. We have decided to hire Danielle on a recurring basis to watch our toddler at least 1-2 times per week. I definitely recommend hiring Danielle and we can't wait to work with her again (and feel so lucky to have found her!).”

Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

Children playing together

How much does an infant babysitter cost in Muttontown, NY?

  • Average hourly rate for 1 child: $25.84
  • Average hourly rate for 2 children: $31.29
  • Typical infant babysitting job length: 5.1 hours
  • Most requested times: Morning

As of November 2026

Recent babysitting activity in Muttontown, NY

Safety is a priority when it comes to your baby

Every babysitter on UrbanSitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See reviews from Muttontown parents before you book.

1,655 sitters background checked in Muttontown, NY

4.9 average star rating from 8,354 parent reviews in Muttontown

photo of quoted parent Talia

"Savannah was very sweet playing with our infant. He was very happy taking a bottle from her, going on a walk, and reading a book."

Talia L., parent

photo of quoted parent Rachel

"Leanna was very sweet and good with our daughter. She played with her, changed her diaper, fed her and all the good things that a newborn needs."

Rachel M., parent

stock photo of a parent

"Was our first time leaving our newborn with a sitter. Emily's calm demeanor put us at ease when we left, and she was great about sending us updates."

Andrea Z., parent

Family with caregiver

Find a great infant sitter in Muttontown

Browse profiles and read parent reviews for free.

Why families use UrbanSitter for infant care in Muttontown

Trusted in your Muttontown community

See infant babysitters connected to families in your Muttontown neighborhood. Know who nearby parents rely on for infant care.

Infant care experience you can see

Detailed profiles show each babysitter's infant experience, listed skills, certifications, and qualifications.

Reviewed by Muttontown parents

Read reviews from local families who have trusted their infant with a sitter. See which babysitters are repeat favorites.

Background checked and reviewed

Every babysitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is reviewed by our Trust and Safety team.

Frequently asked questions about infant babysitters in Muttontown

Are infant babysitters available in Muttontown?

Yes. Browse infant babysitter profiles on UrbanSitter in Muttontown, NY. New sitters with infant experience join regularly.

How much does an infant babysitter cost in Muttontown?

As of November 2026, the average infant babysitting rate in Muttontown is $25.84 per hour for one child. Rates vary by experience and time of day. See average rates by city.

What should I ask an infant babysitter before hiring?

Most parents ask about experience with babies under 12 months, feeding and napping routines, CPR certification, and how the sitter handles fussiness. See our babysitter interview questions guide.

Can I find a last-minute infant babysitter in Muttontown?

Yes. If you need care soon, share your timing and care needs so available sitters can respond. Then review profiles, infant experience, and parent reviews before booking.

Are infant babysitters in Muttontown background checked?

Yes. Every babysitter on UrbanSitter, including those in Muttontown, completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See what's included in the background check.

How do I know if a babysitter is good with infants?

You can check their UrbanSitter profile for years of infant experience, read reviews from other parents with babies, and look at repeat family stats. You can also book a working interview for a trial visit to see if the sitter is the right match for your family.

As seen on