Find infant babysitters in Bay Shore, NY

Meet infant babysitters Bay Shore families trust, with parent reviews, background checks, and detailed profiles.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

13 experienced infant babysitters in Bay Shore, NY

Families in Bay Shore use UrbanSitter for date nights, newborn care, overnight babysitting, and last-minute infant sitters.

All babysitters shown here are background checked every year. Learn more.

Profile photo
Angie Bay Shore
$20 per hour for 1 child

Hello :) My name is Angie i currently go to suffolk community college! I would be more than happy to take care of your baby/child!. Ive always loved kids and have such a soft spot for them!. I take care of two sisters of age 3 and 11 as well as my baby cousins and i enjoy every second of it!. If you were to ask me my experience for childcare it would be years. I have experience with all age of children!. Happy to also take care of your puppies/dogs! as long as their friendly & harmless! I have experience because i have a doggy myself! .

Profile photo
Kaitlyn West Islip
$20 per hour for 1 child

Hi! My name is Kaitlyn, and I recently graduated from The College of New Jersey with a degree in Psychology & Elementary Education. I am continuing my education next year to earn my master’s degree in Special Education. I have several years of experience working with children through summer camps, tutoring, volunteer programs, and classroom placements. I have worked with children of different ages and abilities, including students with special needs. Responsibilities have included supervising activities, helping with homework, creating fun crafts and games, preparing meals/snacks, and keeping daily routines running smoothly. Families would describe me as patient, caring, responsible, and energetic. I love building positive relationships with children and creating a safe, supportive environment where they feel comfortable and engaged. I am also happy to help with light household tasks, organization, meal prep, and pet care.

Profile photo
Jordan
Booked by 1 repeat family
2 reviews
Oakdale
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 2 families in Bay Shore, NY

Hello! My name is Jordan. I have a bachelor’s degree in Early Childhood and Childhood Education with a concentration in English and a Masters degree in Literacy through Pace University! I have completed hundreds of hours student teaching as well as occasionally substituting when needed. I am originally from Long Island, New York and for the past two winters I have lived in Hawaii then Puerto Rico. I love babysitting and have been doing so since I was 12 years old for family and friends! I have experiences with a large range of ages from both babysitting and teaching. I am allergic to cats but happy to work with families with dogs. Additionally, I am open to doing some house work. I can cook, clean, and run errands.

Jordan was so great & our kids loved her. Definitely would recommend

Profile photo
daniella Smithtown
$18 per hour for 1 child

Hi parents! My name is Daniella, and caring for children is something I love, not just a job, but something I take pride in. I have several years of hands-on babysitting experience caring for children of various ages, from infants and toddlers to school-aged kids. I’ve worked with families long-term and on an as-needed basis, which has taught me how to adapt quickly to each child’s unique personality, routine, and needs. I’m a responsible, patient, and nurturing caregiver who believes children thrive best when they feel safe, understood, and encouraged. I’m great at building strong connections with kids while also maintaining structure and clear boundaries that parents can trust. Whether it’s helping with homework, preparing meals, sticking to bedtime routines, or keeping kids engaged with creative activities, I always aim to make time together both fun and meaningful. I bring a calm, positive energy into every home and pride myself on being dependable, organized, and communicative with parents. I’m attentive, safety-focused, and always proactive, anticipating needs before they become problems. Parents often describe me as trustworthy, warm, and someone their children feel comfortable with right away. Some of my strengths include, creating fun, screen-free activities (arts & crafts, games, reading, outdoor play), helping with homework and supporting learning, maintaining routines and bedtime schedules, handling multiple children with patience and care, being reliable, punctual, and respectful of family values. Above all, I care deeply about the well-being of the children I look after. I strive to be someone parents can fully rely on and someone kids genuinely enjoy spending time with. I would love the opportunity to support your family and provide your children with safe, attentive, and loving care.

Profile photo
Rori Farmingdale
$15 per hour for 1 child

Im a college student at the university of Pittsburgh studying pre med. I have experience dog walking and sitting. I am very active and like to run/ walk with the dogs I care for.

Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

Recent babysitting activity in Bay Shore, NY

Safety is a priority when it comes to your baby

Every babysitter on UrbanSitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See reviews from Bay Shore parents before you book.

photo of quoted parent Talia

"Savannah was very sweet playing with our infant. He was very happy taking a bottle from her, going on a walk, and reading a book."

Talia L., parent

photo of quoted parent Rachel

"Leanna was very sweet and good with our daughter. She played with her, changed her diaper, fed her and all the good things that a newborn needs."

Rachel M., parent

stock photo of a parent

"Was our first time leaving our newborn with a sitter. Emily's calm demeanor put us at ease when we left, and she was great about sending us updates."

Andrea Z., parent

Find a great infant sitter in Bay Shore

Browse profiles and read parent reviews for free.

Why families use UrbanSitter for infant care in Bay Shore

Trusted in your Bay Shore community

See infant babysitters connected to families in your Bay Shore neighborhood. Know who nearby parents rely on for infant care.

Infant care experience you can see

Detailed profiles show each babysitter's infant experience, listed skills, certifications, and qualifications.

Reviewed by Bay Shore parents

Read reviews from local families who have trusted their infant with a sitter. See which babysitters are repeat favorites.

Background checked and reviewed

Every babysitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is reviewed by our Trust and Safety team.

Frequently asked questions about infant babysitters in Bay Shore

Are infant babysitters available in Bay Shore?

Yes. Browse infant babysitter profiles on UrbanSitter in Bay Shore, NY. New sitters with infant experience join regularly.

How much does an infant babysitter cost in Bay Shore?

As of [Month/Year], the average infant babysitting rate in Bay Shore is $_ per hour for one child. Rates vary by experience and time of day. See average rates by city.

What should I ask an infant babysitter before hiring?

Most parents ask about experience with babies under 12 months, feeding and napping routines, CPR certification, and how the sitter handles fussiness. See our babysitter interview questions guide.

Can I find a last-minute infant babysitter in Bay Shore?

Yes. If you need care soon, share your timing and care needs so available sitters can respond. Then review profiles, infant experience, and parent reviews before booking.

Are infant babysitters in Bay Shore background checked?

Yes. Every babysitter on UrbanSitter, including those in Bay Shore, completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See what's included in the background check.

How do I know if a babysitter is good with infants?

You can check their UrbanSitter profile for years of infant experience, read reviews from other parents with babies, and look at repeat family stats. You can also book a working interview for a trial visit to see if the sitter is the right match for your family.

As seen on