Find infant babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Meet infant babysitters Shelter Island families trust, with parent reviews, background checks, and detailed profiles.

Looking for jobs? Apply here.

Experienced infant babysitters in Shelter Island, NY

Families in Shelter Island use UrbanSitter for date nights, newborn care, overnight babysitting, and last-minute infant sitters.

All babysitters shown here are background checked every year. Learn more.

Profile photo
Caitlin
Booked by 1 repeat family
1 review
Clinton
$18 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 1 family in Shelter Island, NY

I have experience caring for school-age children, about 4 years old and up, and I’m also comfortable caring for dogs of all breeds and sizes. With kids, I’m happy to help with playtime, crafts, outdoor activities, homework, meals, and keeping their normal routine going. I try to be patient, calm, and easygoing while still making sure everyone is safe and cared for. I also love dogs and have experience with walking, feeding, playing, and giving them attention based on their personality and needs. I’m comfortable with different energy levels and know how important it is to follow each family’s routine. Families can expect me to be dependable, respectful of their home, and attentive to both children and pets.

Caitlin is extremely reliable, has a lot of experience with kids and pets, has a fantastic handle on any emergency situation that may arise, would highly recommend her for any sitting. She has a love for both kids and pets

Profile photo
Kelsey Meriden
$20 per hour for 1 child

I work full-time in architecture and have over 20 years of experience caring for children of all ages and needs, from newborns through teens. I enjoy arts and crafts, science experiments, cooking, and active play, and I thoughtfully adapt my care to each child and family. I’m CPR certified with a clean driving record. My experience includes light household chores, meal prep, school pick-ups and drop-offs, bedtime routines, homework help, and supporting multiples and children with special needs. I currently volunteer with Big Brothers Big Sisters (6.5 years) and serve on the board of NOMAct, where I chair K–12 outreach and lead fun, hands-on architectural learning for kids.

Profile photo
Jillian
Booked by 2 repeat families
1 review
Bridgeport
$25 per hour for 1 child
Booked by 2 families in Shelter Island, NY

I’m a grandmother with over 30 years of hands-on experience caring for children of all ages. I’m patient, loving, reliable, and skilled in routines, safety, meals, and play. I’ve also supported seniors and managed household needs with care and attention.

Live near a college or university? View babysitters by college

Recent babysitting activity in Shelter Island, NY

Safety is a priority when it comes to your baby

Every babysitter on UrbanSitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See reviews from Shelter Island parents before you book.

photo of quoted parent Talia

"Savannah was very sweet playing with our infant. He was very happy taking a bottle from her, going on a walk, and reading a book."

Talia L., parent

photo of quoted parent Rachel

"Leanna was very sweet and good with our daughter. She played with her, changed her diaper, fed her and all the good things that a newborn needs."

Rachel M., parent

stock photo of a parent

"Was our first time leaving our newborn with a sitter. Emily's calm demeanor put us at ease when we left, and she was great about sending us updates."

Andrea Z., parent

Find a great infant sitter in Shelter Island

Browse profiles and read parent reviews for free.

Why families use UrbanSitter for infant care in Shelter Island

Trusted in your Shelter Island community

See infant babysitters connected to families in your Shelter Island neighborhood. Know who nearby parents rely on for infant care.

Infant care experience you can see

Detailed profiles show each babysitter's infant experience, listed skills, certifications, and qualifications.

Reviewed by Shelter Island parents

Read reviews from local families who have trusted their infant with a sitter. See which babysitters are repeat favorites.

Background checked and reviewed

Every babysitter completes an annual background check, and every profile is reviewed by our Trust and Safety team.

Frequently asked questions about infant babysitters in Shelter Island

Are infant babysitters available in Shelter Island?

Yes. Browse infant babysitter profiles on UrbanSitter in Shelter Island, NY. New sitters with infant experience join regularly.

How much does an infant babysitter cost in Shelter Island?

As of [Month/Year], the average infant babysitting rate in Shelter Island is $_ per hour for one child. Rates vary by experience and time of day. See average rates by city.

What should I ask an infant babysitter before hiring?

Most parents ask about experience with babies under 12 months, feeding and napping routines, CPR certification, and how the sitter handles fussiness. See our babysitter interview questions guide.

Can I find a last-minute infant babysitter in Shelter Island?

Yes. If you need care soon, share your timing and care needs so available sitters can respond. Then review profiles, infant experience, and parent reviews before booking.

Are infant babysitters in Shelter Island background checked?

Yes. Every babysitter on UrbanSitter, including those in Shelter Island, completes an annual background check, and every profile is individually reviewed by our Trust and Safety team. See what's included in the background check.

How do I know if a babysitter is good with infants?

You can check their UrbanSitter profile for years of infant experience, read reviews from other parents with babies, and look at repeat family stats. You can also book a working interview for a trial visit to see if the sitter is the right match for your family.

As seen on